Clueless about Carrier Vetting?


I speak all the time about carrier vetting and compliance on the Tell Me Everything Podcast Fraud Girl Friday episodes. This is something that I have always been passionate about and find so interesting because it’s ever-evolving. The most recent change has been the court ruling that brought back into the forefront how important safety is, not just cargo theft prevention.
Ask yourself... Carrier Vetting Is Changing. Is Your Company Keeping Up?
I’ll admit, I was one that if the safety rating wasn’t unsatisfactory or conditional, I was like, let’s go. I think we honestly all were like that. I have spoken with enough customers who knew that inspections, let alone safety ratings, were done few and far between and didn’t always represent how that carrier actually operated on the road. OR, the carrier may have had a bad driver or a driver who made a mistake and terminated them. Should that make the entire carrier look bad and potentially go out of business?
Myself, and really the whole industry, have built carrier vetting processes heavily around cargo theft prevention because, well, we had to.
I have good news: We really have been making a difference!
According to the recent CargoNet Q2 results, overall cargo theft incidents have gone down. They've gone down 26% from Q2 2025 vs Q2 2026. I believe that is because, as an industry, we have been putting those processes in place and making it harder and harder for the bad guys to just snag and grab anything. Plus my amazing men and women out there in blue are cracking down and putting more and more behind bars and crashing down these operations!
However, those same results show that the average stolen load value has more than doubled. Which means the bad guys are targeting higher-value freight and pulling out all the stops to do so. Estimated losses reached $304.6 million, more than double the $135.7 million estimated for Q2 2025, as several multimillion-dollar thefts sharply increased financial severity. Sourced here
In a recent three-hour session (yes, I said THREE hours) I did at the TIA Regional Meeting in Birmingham, AL, Scott Cornell commented on a new method that has popped up where high-value freight had an escort service, that escort was bumped off the road, and then the driver drove off, went down the road to a truck stop, had that trailer unloaded, and the freight was gone. He clarified that this wasn’t necessarily a violent method, but it has escalated, and we have not seen this before.
Even with those bump-and-runs, it came down to carrier vetting. The carrier still was not up to par, and you can have all the measures of security after the load is picked up, but that pre-vetting is still SO important!
Here I go talking about cargo theft again! That’s not what I wanted this article to be about haha!
Let me get back on track.
I have had many brokers reach out to me about safety vetting. How do I even do this? Like I mentioned, most of us weren’t digging into the SMS (Safety Measurement System) site and looking at all the details. The question is, do we need to now?
There isn’t a simple checklist that automatically makes a carrier safe. There is no guaranteed safe harbor that says checking these three or four boxes will eliminate a broker’s potential exposure or legal risk. What is important is the process and the documentation.
So what should you do?
Start off by making sure you have a clear, written carrier selection policy. NOT just what your risk assessment says within your carrier vetting or onboarding product, although that’s a great reference to build off of.
Christie Brush - DeLatte from Trident Insurance said, Insurance companies are wanting to see this as they write your policies, and they want to see more than just, “We use this vetting platform.” They want to see an actual policy explaining what information the company considers when determining whether a carrier meets its requirements.
That way, IF a carrier is involved in a serious accident, the question may not simply be, did the carrier have authority and insurance? It becomes: What information was available when the carrier was selected? What did the company review? What did your own policy require? And most importantly, did you follow it and document it?
The FMCSA makes a significant amount of carrier information publicly available. Depending on a broker’s policy, that review may include items such as the carrier’s operating status, safety rating when one exists, inspection history, driver and vehicle out-of-service information, crashes, and other publicly available safety information.
The challenge I think we are all facing is: What does that information actually mean?
A carrier having a higher-than-average out-of-service percentage, for example, doesn’t tell the entire story. What should you look at beyond that? How many inspections produced that percentage, and when did they occur? Context matters. Don’t create standards you are not willing to follow when it’s Friday at 4:50 p.m., a driver breaks down, and you’re trying to get out for the weekend.
If you make your written policy too tight where most carriers fail, we all have been in the business long enough to know that thats when you'll make exceptions, and exceptions is where you get in trouble. That’s when you start getting into a situation where your process may not be defensible.
Is this article going to tell you exactly what you should do and what policy you should write? Honestly, no. Everyone has different business needs, ships different freight, has different lanes, and uses different types of carriers.
What I am looking at doing is offering Fraud Girl Consulting, where I can sit down with your compliance team and legal representation, see how you vet carriers now, look at what things I recommend changing based on what I have seen throughout the industry and the technology that you have, and help you write out a policy that makes sense for your business.
After you have that policy in place, make sure the technology you have enforces that policy. Which really comes into your TMS.
I spoke with Dale Prax who works heavily with FMCSA directly and really has pioneered the relationship between public and private sector of transportation, he told me, if a carrier has been dinged for english proficiency you as a broker should take that red flag and ask the question if the carrier has made changes where they no longer hire non english proficient drivers. Or let's say a carrier has braking issues time and time again, asking the carrier (not driver) for a pre-check inspection report ensuring that the companies truck is up to par with government standards. It's asking the questions based on the red flags... does this take extra time, yes. However, we got used to the same standards with cargo theft prevention just copy and paste to safety vetting and that process should become quicker and quicker.
Since this is Fraud Girl, I also want to talk about the distinction between safety vetting and cargo security verification.
Safety vetting asks whether the motor carrier meets the company’s standards for selection. Cargo security verification may ask whether the person communicating is really connected to the carrier, whether the expected driver arrived at pickup, whether that carrier’s physical footprint matches the lane they’re trying to pick up, whether they have hauled that type of equipment before, and whether the truck and trailer match the information provided. Many of those processes overlap, but they are not necessarily the same thing.
One example discussed during the panel that I think is VERY important to highlight, because this is something I have been preaching for well over a year now, is driver-level information. Since the most recent verdict, what you don’t want to get into is the borrowed servant/borrowed employee issue, as it came up in the context of vicarious liability and control over the driver.
The basic concern is this: A broker hires an independent motor carrier, and the carrier employs or contracts with the driver. But if the broker starts exercising too much control over how that driver performs the work, a plaintiff can argue that the driver was effectively acting as the broker’s borrowed employee/servant. That potentially creates another path for trying to hold the broker responsible for the driver’s conduct.
That ties directly into the distinction between driver identification and driver qualification.
Driver identification: “Is this actually the driver the carrier dispatched?”
Driver qualification/control: “Is this driver qualified to drive? What’s their driving history? How should they drive? What route should they take? When should they stop?”
Vet the carrier without accidentally taking over the carrier’s job of employing and managing the driver.
So based on the wise advise of Justin Olsen, what I have changed (and others should as well) is instead of saying we need to go beyond carrier vetting and go down to driver vetting, I am using the words - driver identification.
That doesn’t mean brokers shouldn’t verify who is picking up their customer’s freight. Confirming that the person who arrives is the driver the motor carrier dispatched is very different from attempting to independently qualify that driver as though the broker were the driver’s employer. Honestly, should be more of a shipper responsibility than a broker but the broker needs to advise who is showing up.
The same caution applies after dispatch. Telling a carrier where freight needs to be picked up and delivered is part of arranging transportation. Dictating how the driver performs the transportation (routes, driving methods, hours, breaks, or other operational details) can raise a different set of questions.
During our discussion, Tony Bennett made a great point when he said that the language from his broker-carrier agreement makes it clear that the carrier controls the driver and how the transportation is performed.
He also said his agreement states:
“Carrier shall perform the services hereunder as an independent contractor.”
The carrier is solely responsible for determining whether the scheduled services can be completed without violating applicable laws.
There was also a point made about avoiding evidence that the broker exercised control over the driver/carrier. If the shipper has a route requirement or suggestion, such as don’t stop for the first 200 miles, avoid this area, or use this route, the broker can communicate that. But the documentation should make clear that the broker is relaying the shipper/customer’s instruction rather than independently directing how the motor carrier operates.
So instead of documenting:
“We instructed the driver to take I-XX and not stop for 200 miles.”
The record should look more like:
“Relayed shipper’s requested security instructions to motor carrier: [instructions]. Carrier acknowledged receipt.”
Or:
“Customer-provided security requirements were communicated to the motor carrier. Broker is relaying customer requirements; motor carrier remains responsible for the safe and lawful operation of its equipment and driver.”
I would also avoid internal notes like “told driver where to drive,” “required driver to take this route,” “driver must follow our route,” or “instructed driver not to stop.”
Better wording is “relayed,” “communicated,” “shipper requested,” “customer security requirement,” and “carrier acknowledged.”
So what was the overall learning lesson here?
There is no carrier selection process that can predict every accident. A carrier can meet every requirement and look squeaky clean with a perfect driving record and still get into a serious accident tomorrow. It can happen to us as personal drivers the same way (knock on wood).
That is not what brokers are trying to achieve.
It’s more about having a carrier selection process that is consistent, thoughtful, and defensible.
Have a written process. Make sure everyone on your team is well-trained and well-versed on the expectations of that written policy. Know why you chose your thresholds. Establish how exceptions are handled. Make sure technology supports those rules. And make sure your broker-carrier agreement and operational practices align.
So it’s not as scary as we thought.
We have been doing this for a long time when it comes to cargo theft, and we’ve been crushing it! Now it’s time to adapt that method to safety.
Cannot wait to hear about what you guys are doing in the field. Be sure to tune into more Tell Me Everything episodes where I do as much digging and learning as I can to help solve that question we are all asking.
We got this!
💛 Thank You to Our Sponsor: Tallgrass Freight Co.
This newsletter is made possible by our friends at Tallgrass Freight Company, the very first sponsor of the Tell Me Everything
If you’re a freight broker agent looking for a brokerage that values relationships, integrity, and giving agents the support they need to grow, I’d encourage you to learn more about their team.
📧 Interested in becoming a Tallgrass Freight agent?
Email: tme@tallgrassfreight.com
Tell them Fraud Girl sent you. 😉




Comments